My guess is some kind of tumbler as well. I've got a blast cabinet I use that has plastic media in it. It will put that kind of shine on the aluminum, but it is not agressive enough to remove stains in the aluminum. On HS2 carbs the shaft rides directly in the aluminum of the carb body, and as a result they don't get sloppy shafts as easily as HS4s where the shafts rides directly in brass bushing in the car body. Most of the time on HS2s the shaft simply wears and the carb body does not. When the shaft hole in the carb body on a HS2 does wear, then you can put a bushing in the carb body to restore it or if the wear is light just ream the carb body out for a .010" oversized shaft.