Jerry,
At the risk of sounding like a nut, I think that a reasonable amount of carbon on the combustion chamber & piston top actually helps power & gas mileage, as long as the buildup is not excessive.
The carbon acts as a thermal barrier to prevent combustion heat loss to the cooling system & to the oil system. This increases the engines thermal efficiency & power. Racers pay big bucks to have ceramic thermal barrier coatings applied to piston tops & combustion chambers. Carbon acts much the same as the ceramic coating. Thermal coating of piston tops on Diesel engines is done quite widely for the same reasons. While not as effective as ceramic coating, the carbon helps & costs nothing. We are only talking gains of around three percent, but still a gain.
On a freshly rebuilt & shiny race engine the power usually increases a bit until a carbon layer has developed. The metal does not stay shiny clean. The only time that carbon is a problem is if it builds up very thick. With proper fuel mixture & no oil burning the carbon will only build up to a minimal stable level & any further carbon burns off. I have pulled down high mileage engines which were still in good shape & the carbon build up was minimal.
The concept of polishing combustion chambers to a shiny finish to prevent carbon build up is largely a waste of time, as the carbon will form again in a very short time anyway.
There may be some difference of opinion on this, but it is something to think about.
D